In-House vs. Outsourced Healthcare Contact Centers: A Cost-Benefit Guide for Hospital Leaders

For hospital leaders, the decision between managing contact centers in-house or outsourcing isn’t just operational—it’s strategic. Rising labor costs, compliance requirements, and patient satisfaction scores all hinge on how your calls are handled. The difference can mean millions saved each year and stronger patient trust.

This cost-benefit analysis reveals the real numbers, compliance considerations, and scalability options to help you make the right call for your hospital’s future.

Coverage, Pricing, and Deductible Changes

With ever-evolving coverage options, we ensure your policyholders stay updated.  

Our team manages changes in coverage, pricing, and deductibles, guaranteeing your customers are always well-informed.

Premium Increase Management

When premium increases raise concerns, our knowledgeable agents step in. We assist callers with enrollee changes, address updates, coverage adjustments, and billing alterations.

Our agents excel at implementing upselling and cross-selling strategies to retain customers even in the face of premium hikes.

Chapter I: Why This Matters
  
Chapter I

Why This In-House vs. Outsourced Healthcare Call Centers Decision Matters

Managing hospital finances means every operational decision impacts your bottom line. The choice between in-house vs. outsourced healthcare call centers can shift your budget by millions, affect patient satisfaction scores and alter your compliance risk profile. This guide breaks down the real numbers so you can make an informed decision for your organization.

  
Chapter II

Outsourcing vs. In-House Healthcare Contact Center

Criteria In-House Contact Center Outsourced Contact Center
Cost Structure Salaries, benefits, technology upgrades, ongoing training Per-call or per-minute fees with bundled services
Scalability Limited by hiring timelines and training capacity Rapid scaling up or down based on demand
Compliance Direct oversight with internal audit processes Vendor demonstrates HIPAA, HITRUST, and SOC2 compliance
Integration Custom EHR/PMS integration requiring IT resources Vendor-provided APIs with dedicated integration support
Performance Depends on staffing levels, turnover and team morale Contract-based SLAs with 24/7 coverage and higher first-call resolution
Cost Predictability Variable with hidden overhead costs Transparent, contract-based pricing
  
Chapter III

Healthcare Call Center Cost Analysis: The Real Numbers

According to industry data, the typical healthcare call center runs about $13.9 million annually. Labor costs eat up $6 million of that budget (43%), covering hiring, training, benefits and turnover replacement. Break it down per interaction, and you’re looking at an average of $4.90 per call. Some facilities hit $10-$15 per call when you factor in all the hidden costs.

Picture a 350-agent center handling 26,250 calls daily. That’s $128,625 in daily operating expenses.

Outsourced healthcare call centers typically charge $0.96 to $1.84 per call. Most hospitals see cost savings of outsourced healthcare call centers between 25% and 30% compared to running operations internally. Plus, you skip the massive upfront technology investments.

call-centers-high-cost
  
Chapter IV

Benefits of Outsourcing Medical Call Centers

Workforce Flexibility

Your outsourcing partner scales staff for flu season spikes, new service launches or marketing campaigns without you posting job listings or conducting interviews.

Performance Standards

Many providers guarantee shorter hold times and better first-call resolution rates than most internal teams achieve.

Compliance Expertise

Top vendors live and breathe Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) regulations.

Technology Access

Get tools powered by artificial intelligence (AI), automated appointment reminders and real-time analytics dashboards without the IT headaches.

  
Chapter V

Hospital Call Center Outsourcing Pros and Cons

Outsourced Advantages

  • Lower, predictable monthly costs
  • Fast scalability for demand changes
  • Advanced technology and analytics tools
  • Built-in compliance expertise

Outsourced Challenges

  • Less direct day-to-day control
  • Service provider selection and setup process
  • Data security depends on vendor capabilities
  • Integration may need IT coordination

In-House Advantages

  • Complete operational oversight
  • Custom-built processes for your facility
  • Internal data security management

In-House Challenges

  • Higher costs that are difficult to scale
  • Constant recruiting, training and turnover management
  • Ongoing technology upgrades and compliance costs
        
Chapter VI

Addressing Your Concerns

Compliance Questions

Leading vendors provide comprehensive documentation and regular audit reports. Request proof of HIPAA, Health Information Trust Alliance (HITRUST), and System and Organization Controls 2 (SOC2) compliance before signing any contracts. 

Integration Worries

Most established providers offer seamless electronic health record (EHR) and performance management system (PMS) integration with dedicated onboarding teams to handle the technical details.

Patient Experience

Outsourced teams often match or exceed in-house satisfaction scores, thanks to specialized healthcare training and advanced technology tools.

    
Chapter VII

Healthcare Contact Center Cost Comparison: Real Example

According to industry data, a regional hospital processing 20,000 monthly calls pays roughly $4.90 per call with its in-house team (including all overhead). On average, outsourcing drops that cost to $1.20 per call.

That’s cost savings of outsourced healthcare call centers totaling $74,000 per month or nearly $900,000 annually.

hospital-interior
Chapter VIII

Calculate Your Savings Now

See the real financial impact of outsourcing vs. keeping operations in-house.

Using industry benchmarks, you can compare your current call center costs to projected outsourced costs and uncover the potential annual savings for your organization. 

Average in-house cost

$4–$6 per call (including overhead, staffing, and compliance).

Average in-house cost

Average outsourced cost

$1–$2 per call, with volume discounts available.

Average outsourced cost

Typical savings

25–30% annually on contact center operations.

Typical savings

Equation

Use our medical call center analysis to estimate your potential savings:

Your Call Volume × Avg. Cost per Call ($4.90) = Your Estimated Cost

Example

A hospital spending $6 million yearly on in-house operations could save $1.5 million to $2 million annually through outsourcing.

This return-on-investment (ROI) calculation uses industry benchmarks, combined with your actual data, for a personalized healthcare call center analysis.

 

Adjust the slider below to see how changes in call volume impact your estimated annual savings.

Weekly call volume
Annual savings
Contact Sales
Annual in-house cost
Annual outsourced cost

Take the Next Step with Working Solutions

Ready to transform your healthcare contact center operations? Schedule a consultation with our healthcare specialists to identify immediate improvement opportunities. Let’s work together to elevate your healthcare support services!

Speak to an Expert
Who We are

Working Solutions provides virtual contact center outsourcing that measurably improves customer experiences (CX). We deliver high-quality, all-encompassing solutions for your fluctuating sales and service needs. Our on-demand CX expertise enables you to better engage, empathize with and delight customers, wherever and whenever they interact with your brand.